Key point: Since our July post, the first motion to dismiss under the Virginia Personal Information Privacy Act has been fully briefed, and three more national retailers have been sued under the statute in complaints that appear built to close the pleading gaps the first defendant identified.
In July, we flagged a putative class action in the Eastern District of Virginia against a national home-improvement retailer under the Virginia Personal Information Privacy Act (VPIPA), a decades-old statute that had produced exactly one prior lawsuit. You can read our prior article here.
The retailer’s motion to dismiss is now fully briefed. Between October 27 and November 13, three more national retailers were hit with putative class actions under the same statute. This post covers where the first case stands, what the new complaints allege, and what retailers with Virginia stores can do now.
The First Case: Motion to Dismiss Pending
The plaintiff in the first case alleges that the retailer fed customer information gathered at its stores into a data clean room operated by a data broker, which enhanced the data through “identity resolution,” and that the retailer then sold access to the enhanced product to brands through its retail media network. The retailer moved to dismiss under Rules 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(6) on September 28.
The court has not yet ruled. The plaintiff opposed on October 13, and the retailer replied on October 23. The court has set a pretrial conference for December 17, 2026. Three merits disputes in the briefing will matter for every case that follows.
[1] The Link to an In-Store Sale. The statute reaches only information “gathered in connection with the sale, rental, or exchange of tangible personal property to the purchaser at the merchant’s place of business.” The retailer argued that the complaint never alleged the date, product, payment method, or information the plaintiff supplied at checkout. It also argued that the complaint’s own lengthy description of website and app data collection supplied an obvious alternative source for the data.
The plaintiff answered that Rule 8 does not require a receipt and that how the retailer linked his identity to his purchases is a fact about the retailer’s own systems. He also relied on the 2020 Massachusetts decision discussed in our July post, which sustained a complaint alleging shopping during “an unspecified period of time.” The reply distinguished that decision by arguing that the complaint in that case had three allegations missing from the case at bar: (1) cashiers requesting names and addresses; (2) junk mail that followed; and (3) a data broker listing offering the retailer’s customer data. The reply also argued that an item-level purchase record does not “concern[] the purchaser” until it is tied to an identified person, and that on the plaintiff’s own theory, that tie happens downstream inside the clean room.
[2] Whether a Data Exchange Is a “Sale”. The retailer pointed out that the complaint describes “trading” data for enhanced data and processing capability, not “selling” it for cash. The plaintiff responded with Virginia’s version of the Uniform Commercial Code, under which a price “can be made payable in money or otherwise.” In its reply, the retailer noted that the 2014 amendment to the VPIPA addressing driver’s-license scanning prohibits merchants from selling “or disseminat[ing]” that information, while the provision asserted in this (and the other) lawsuits (§ 59.1-442(A)) still says only “sell.” It also argued that the Consumer Data Protection Act (CDPA) ties its own definition of “sale” to monetary consideration.
[3] Whether a Website Privacy Statement Is Notice. Under the VPIPA, notice “may be by the posting of a sign or any other reasonable method.” In the motion-to-dismiss briefing, the retailer pointed to its online privacy statement, which discloses in-store collection, sharing with “business partners and marketing partners,” and a mechanism to opt out. The complaint never alleges that the plaintiff opted out using the provisions in the online privacy statement.
In his opposition, the plaintiff argued that the statute’s chosen example, a sign, suggests notice that reaches a shopper standing in the store, not a statement that is available online. The plaintiff also argued that a general reference to marketing partners in an online privacy statement is not notice that purchase data goes to a data broker for identity resolution. In its reply, the retailer responded that nothing in the text of the statute confines notice to the four walls of the store, and that the CDPA’s own privacy-notice requirement shows a published privacy statement is a “reasonable method.”
Three New Complaints, One Template
The first-in-recent-time VPIPA complaint was filed in July 2026. Three more putative class actions followed in quick succession: one against a national big-box retailer in the Western District of Virginia on October 27, one against a national discount chain in the Middle District of Tennessee on November 9, and one against a national beauty retailer in the Northern District of Illinois on November 13.
All three were filed by the same group of plaintiffs’ firms, which is not the group behind the first case. Large portions of the three complaints — including the allegations about the value of first-party data, the injury theories, and the class allegations — are nearly identical. Each seeks $100 per violation on behalf of every person who made an in-store purchase at the retailer’s Virginia locations during the limitations period. These three complaints attempt to preclude the issues identified in the first-filed motion to dismiss and circumvent potential dismissal.
[1] The Link to an In-Store Sale. Each new complaint pleads a specific transaction, identifying a specific store, date, amount, and payment method. Each also alleges no sign at the store entrance, checkout area, or payment terminal. The discount chain complaint goes a step further and alleges that the plaintiffs did not use a loyalty program, app, online account, digital coupon, or membership number, and did not agree to any terms at checkout.
None of the new complaints alleges that a cashier asked for a name or address. They instead rely on payment cards to supply the link to an identifiable person. The big-box complaint cites published reporting on an executive interview stating that in-store card transactions can be matched to an “anonymized ID” mapped to an individual. It also cites a vendor promotional video in which an executive described using the vendor to “connect people in-store with their online identity.” The discount chain complaint quotes the retailer’s media network as describing more than 90 million “active and trackable” customer profiles and an objective of “increasing customer match finding signals in offline transactions.” The beauty retailer complaint relies on a 2020 case study describing the integration of in-store purchases into ad measurement on a social media platform, and alleges the link to the plaintiff on information and belief.
[2] Whether a Data Exchange Is a “Sale”. None of the new complaints alleges the transfer of a customer list. Instead, each alleges that purchase-based audience segments, clean-room matching, closed-loop sales measurement, and — in the big-box complaint — insight subscriptions sold to suppliers are “sales” of purchaser information. Each also alleges that pseudonymizing, aggregating, or segmenting the data does not take it outside “information that concerns the purchaser.” The discount chain complaint cites the defendant’s Form 10-K, which states that cash consideration from vendors includes amounts received through its media network.
Each complaint also quotes the respective defendant-retailer’s privacy policy disclosures under other state privacy laws to support its allegations that the defendants’ behavior is a “sale.” The big-box complaint quotes a statement that certain disclosures “may be deemed selling under certain state privacy laws.” The discount chain complaint quotes a notice listing “commercial information, such as transaction information, purchase history and financial details” among the categories sold to advertising partners, for account holders and non-account holders alike. The beauty retailer complaint quotes a notice that the retailer “sell[s]” and “share[s]” personal information “as defined under California law.”
[3] Whether a Website Privacy Statement Is Notice. Each of the three complaints also includes allegations to try to circumvent any argument that an online privacy statement provides the “notice” required under the VPIPA. The big-box and beauty retailer complaints allege that the disclosures are “not readily apparent” to in-store purchasers, and the discount chain complaint alleges that the defendant’s policy “is not itself a posted sign or point-of-sale communication to an ordinary in-store purchaser who never visits the website during the transaction.”
The complaints also seek to limit “notice” to the moment of purchase. Each pleads that there was no sign at the store entrance, checkout area, or payment terminal. The discount chain complaint adds checkout screens, receipts, and cashiers to that list, and alleges that plaintiffs were not required to visit the website, create an account, or accept online terms to complete the purchase. Critically, the complaints do not allege that a website can never provide notice. They instead allege that the websites for these defendants for these purchases for these plaintiffs did not provide notice.
Each complaint also ties the lack of notice to the statute’s opt-out right, alleging that the plaintiff “had no opportunity” to ask the retailer not to sell. Although some of the policies describe an opt-out mechanism, the complaints allege that a customer who is never told of a sale has no reason to ask that it stop.
None of the complaints addresses the argument, raised in the motion-to-dismiss briefing discussed above, that the CDPA’s privacy-notice requirement makes a published privacy statement a “reasonable method” to provide notice.
What Retailers Should Do Now
The VPIPA spent three decades generating almost no case law. It is about to generate some, likely from four courts in three circuits at roughly the same time. While retailers with physical stores in Virginia await further guidance about the reach (and limitations) of the VPIPA, here are four things to do to avoid adding to the growing number of complaints being filed under this law:
- Consider point-of-sale notice. Under the plaintiffs’ interpretation of the statute, notice must reach the shopper at or before the in-store transaction, and a website privacy statement does not count. Every complaint filed so far alleges the absence of a sign at the entrance, checkout, or payment terminal. Whether or not that interpretation holds up, a short sign or payment-terminal message stating that information from in-store purchases may be sold, and how to ask that it not be, would take the allegation off the table at little cost.
- Make the opt-out easy to find and use without an account. The plaintiffs read the statute to require that an in-store purchaser have a practical opportunity to request that his information not be sold, and each new complaint alleges the plaintiff “had no opportunity” to do so. Retailers can blunt that theory by describing the opt-out in any in-store notice, offering a channel that does not require an account or login, and confirming that requests actually suppress data tied to in-store transactions.
- Keep dated copies of every privacy statement. In the first case, the parties are already disputing which version of the privacy statement applied when the plaintiff shopped. Two of the new complaints rely on versions updated after the plaintiffs’ purchases. A dated archive lets a retailer show what a customer could have seen on a given day. That matters both for any argument that the statement provided “reasonable” notice and for responding to the complaints’ use of these policies as “sale” admissions.
- Read “sale” disclosures and retail media marketing as a plaintiff would. California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)-style “we sell” language, investor filings, case studies, and executive interviews describing “active and trackable” profiles are being quoted as admissions. Retailers should know what is already in the public record that a plaintiff could cite, including materials published by vendors and partners, and should have legal review new statements about their data practices, including marketing and sales materials, before they are made.